Shelter Island, NY Homes for Sale

Shelter Island $32,000,000 beds: 7 baths: 7.5 4.80 acres 7,000 sq. ft.
Beate Moore Exclusive
Sotheby's International Realty (Bridgehampton)
Shelter Island $13,995,000 beds: 8 baths: 8 2.00 acres 8,000 sq. ft.
Seth Madore Exclusive
Corcoran Group Real Estate (Shelter Island)
Shelter Island $11,995,000 beds: 12 baths: 12.5 4.30 acres 15,470 sq. ft.
Peter M. McCracken Exclusive
Corcoran Group Real Estate (Shelter Island)
Shelter Island $10,995,000 beds: 6 baths: 6.5 1.52 acres 8,000 sq. ft.
Seth Madore Exclusive
Corcoran Group Real Estate (Shelter Island)
Shelter Island $9,995,000 beds: 7 baths: 8 4.10 acres 4,700 sq. ft.
Jonathan Smith Exclusive
Sotheby's International Realty (Southampton)
Shelter Island $9,250,000 beds: 6 baths: 6.5 16.00 acres 5,015 sq. ft.
Penelope Moore Exclusive
Saunders & Associates (Shelter Island)
Shelter Island $8,950,000 beds: 4 baths: 4.5 5.40 acres 8,000 sq. ft.
Christine M. Saar Co-Exclusive
Brown Harris Stevens (East Hampton)
Shelter Island $8,875,000 beds: 7 baths: 8 1.87 acres 7,165 sq. ft.
Penelope Moore Exclusive
Saunders & Associates (Shelter Island)
Shelter Island $8,575,000 beds: 6 baths: 6.5 15.77 acres 5,015 sq. ft.
Penelope Moore Exclusive
Saunders & Associates (Shelter Island)
Shelter Island $7,950,000 beds: 6 baths: 6.5 1.71 acres 9,230 sq. ft.
Gina Surerus
Corcoran Group Real Estate (Shelter Island)
Shelter Island $7,950,000 beds: 6 baths: 6.5 1.71 acres 9,230 sq. ft.
Penelope Moore
Saunders & Associates (Shelter Island)
Shelter Island Price upon request beds: 6 baths: 6 1.71 acres 9,230 sq. ft.
Georgiana B. Ketcham, Lic. RE Broker
Shelter Island $6,991,000 beds: 6 baths: 6.5 1.71 acres 9,230 sq. ft.
Suzanne Sienkiewicz
Nest Seekers International (Southampton)
Shelter Island $6,975,000 beds: 6 baths: 6.5 1.71 acres 9,230 sq. ft.
Barbara Lobosco
Douglas Elliman (Sag Harbor)
Shelter Island $6,450,000 beds: 5 baths: 3.5 1.75 acres 3,492 sq. ft.
Penelope Moore Exclusive
Saunders & Associates (Shelter Island)